Artkive vs. Shutterfly: Which Kids' Artwork Book Is Worth It?
- Sep 6, 2025
- 8 min read
Updated: 12 hours ago
It's the end of the school year, and a thick folder slides out of your kid's backpack: third grade's greatest hits. A self-portrait with a face the size of a watermelon. A habitat diorama that may or may not contain a real twig. You smile, you flip through, and then you have the thought you've had a hundred times: where on earth am I going to put all of this?
If you've ever stood in your kitchen holding a watercolor your kid made when they were four and silently negotiated with yourself about whether you can part with it, this comparison is for you. Two of the most common ways parents turn arts and crafts into a keepsake are Artkive's concierge service and a Shutterfly photo book. Both can produce a beautiful kids' artwork book. The path each one takes to get there is very different.
JUMP TO:
Artkive vs. Shutterfly: Two Ways to Save Your Child's Artwork
Both options can produce a lovely kids' artwork book. The process and the time you invest sit at opposite ends of the spectrum. Here's how each one works.
Artkive: Box-to-Book Concierge Service
The Artkive box has helped over 500,000 families preserve kids' artwork and family memories.
Artkive is a concierge-style service built for parents who want the keepsake without the project. When you sign up, we send a sturdy Artkive box that holds 25 to 200 pieces of any size, from scribble pages to 3D sculptures. You pack it, slap on the prepaid label, and send it back. Our team professionally photographs every piece in our studio, edits each image to capture every color and detail, and designs a clean, museum-quality layout for your book.
You also have the option to turn favorite pieces into a framed mosaic. Once your book is laid out, you'll receive a digital proof with the ability to rearrange pages or add captions. After you approve it, we print and ship your hardcover artwork book. You can even opt to have the originals returned.
Since 2012, we've photographed over 20 million pieces of kids' art and built trust with more than 500,000 families. Parents consistently praise how Artkive turns kids' drawings into a coffee-table-worthy keepsake without asking for a free weekend.
Shutterfly: The "Do-It-Yourself" Kids' Book of Art
Shutterfly is a well-known photo book service that gives crafty parents hands-on creative control over every page.
Here's what making a Shutterfly photo book of your child's artwork actually involves:
First, digitize your child's art by photographing or scanning every piece. Next, upload the images to Shutterfly's site or app and use their photo book design tool to lay out each page. You'll choose themes, arrange pictures, add captions, and customize backgrounds. Shutterfly offers plenty of design options, which crafty parents appreciate. Finally, Shutterfly prints and ships your hardcover photo book.
The process takes time, an eye for design, and a fair amount of technical patience. One mom noted in a Shutterfly review that the site "does not work intuitively," and that she "spent way too much time trying to figure out how to use their templates and move photos around."
If you enjoy the creative process, that's a feature. If your free time is already booked, it's a hurdle.
Which Option Saves You More Time?
When time is the variable, Artkive has a clear advantage for busy parents. With Shutterfly, you photograph or scan every piece, upload and edit each image, then arrange the layout. That's before you factor in lighting, image quality, and your own design skills. A polished result takes hours. Sometimes many hours.
With Artkive, the work on your end is small. You spend a little time sorting and packing the box. We handle the digitizing, editing, and book design. Aside from a quick proof review, there's not much else for you to do.
For many parents, that gap is the whole reason they pick a service in the first place. As one mom told us after trying Artkive:
“Could I make a photo book myself for less? Yes. Would I ever get around to doing it for the kids’ art? Probably not.”
She had years of her kids' baby books and arts and crafts sitting in boxes, waiting. Choosing Artkive ensured the project actually got done.
The truth is that most busy parents intend to make a kids' artwork book themselves. Finding the free evenings to organize, scan, and design one rarely happens. Artkive gives those hours back.
Hassle & Ease of Use: DIY Effort vs. White-Glove Service
Many parents find that creating a Shutterfly photo book of kids' art turns frustrating fast if you're not tech-savvy or design-inclined. You'll navigate the software, choose layouts, and troubleshoot along the way. If you scrapbook for fun, this can be enjoyable. As one parent put it:
“If you know what you’re doing, you can create stunning books... but if not, the options will just overwhelm you.”
The other risk is procrastination. It's easy to put off a project that feels like work, which is how kids' art ends up in a drawer indefinitely.
Artkive's white-glove service is built to be hassle-free. We handle photography, editing, and design. The proof interface is simple to navigate, and our team sends friendly reminders and proofing support along the way, so it feels like there's "a human on the other end" of the process.
The bottom line: Artkive minimizes the chance of error and stress. No template wrestling. No technical glitches. For a busy parent, it's both a time-saver and a stress-saver.
Price Comparison: Budget vs. Value
We can't compare Artkive and Shutterfly without talking about price. There is a real difference, and there's a reason for it.
Shutterfly and other DIY photo book platforms generally cost less. A standard 20-page 8×11″ hardcover Shutterfly photo book runs roughly $50 before shipping. Additional pages are about $1 each, with a max of 111 pages. If you're willing to put in the work, that's a fair value.
Artkive's pricing reflects the white-glove service and labor involved. There's a $39 deposit to receive your Artkive box. Books start at $75 for a 25-page 8.5×11″ hardcover artwork book. Adding more pieces or extra book copies increases the cost (about $1 to $3 per additional piece).
The difference is what you're paying for. With Artkive, the photography, editing, and design are built in. You're outsourcing hours of work to people who do this every day. For many busy parents, that trade is the whole point.
It comes down to whether you'd rather invest a bit more money to save time or invest your personal time to save money. Both choices are valid. Some families use Shutterfly because they enjoy the work and want to make multiple books at a lower per-book cost. Either way, the result is a high-quality kids' artwork book worth keeping.
Shutterfly Kids Art Book: When DIY Makes Sense
Choosing the DIY route with Shutterfly is a smart move in a few scenarios:
You enjoy the creative process. If photo books are a hobby, you may find the work rewarding. Some parents take real pride in customizing each page, choosing backgrounds that match the artwork's theme, and adding personal captions. If "design night" sounds like "me time" rather than another to-do, doing it yourself can be enjoyable.
Budget is the deciding factor. If you have more time than money, Shutterfly is the economical choice. With patience, a DIY book can fit a tight budget, especially if you plan to make several.
The project is small. If you have a handful of pieces to preserve, or you're making a one-off gift, the DIY effort isn't overwhelming. Shutterfly's long track record shows it's possible to DIY and end up with something beautiful. Just block out dedicated time before you start.
When to Choose Artkive: The Time-Saving Memory Book
The Artkive box is a favorite among mom groups for a reason. Low stress. Hassle-free. Premium results. A kids artwork book with museum-quality style.
Choose Artkive when time, ease, and top-tier quality are your priorities. Parents with boxes of artwork piling up appreciate how straightforward the process is. If you've been meaning to digitize your kids' art for years and still haven't, Artkive is the version of the project that actually gets finished.
As one blogger (a dad of two) wrote after using both services:
"For kids’ artwork, I would go with a more expensive but convenient service like Artkive to do the heavy lifting for me. I know Artkive is a little pricey, but I personally found it to be worth every penny." ~ Evan, Dad Fixes Everything
In other words, choose Artkive when you want a sure thing: a beautiful outcome with minimal effort on your part. If you have years of artwork to preserve in one go, this is the better fit. It also works beautifully as a refined keepsake for grandparents or a gift for a future graduate.
Artkive's high-quality books do more than preserve memories. They build kids' confidence. One mom shared in her Artkive review that her son became excited and proud the moment he saw his work in a real book. The bonus: it motivated him to keep creating.
"Since then, {my son} has been conscious of his next art book when working on something. It’s been a good motivator for him to do his best work on projects he wants to include." ~ Danielle Y.
That experience goes beyond the book. It's about celebrating your child's creativity. If that resonates, and you'd rather we handle the work, Artkive is the right fit for your family.
What Makes the Best Kids' Artwork Book?
Most art books on the market fall into two camps: pre-printed coffee-table volumes by professional artists, or DIY photo book templates you fill in yourself. A true kids' artwork book sits in a different category. It's not a stock product, and it's not a scrapbook. It's a curated archive of your child's creative work, designed so they recognize themselves in it.
The best kids' artwork book is the one that actually gets made. It's the one your child pulls off the shelf five years from now and grins at. It's the one a grandparent receives in the mail and calls to thank you for. It's the one a college kid takes with them when they leave home, and the one you're glad you didn't leave on a hard drive somewhere.
Whether the route to that book runs through a DIY platform like Shutterfly or a concierge service like Artkive matters less than this: the project happens.
The Bottom Line: Saving Memories, Saving Time
Both Artkive and Shutterfly are valid ways to preserve your child's artwork. The decision comes down to your personal balance of time, budget, and how much DIY effort you want to take on.
If you're a busy parent short on time and craving a hassle-free children's artwork book, Artkive's send-it-and-forget-it service can take the project off your plate entirely. You'll get a professionally crafted artwork book that honors your child's creativity without adding to your to-do list. If you have the time and enjoy the creative process, a Shutterfly photo book featuring your kids' drawings is a fulfilling DIY project for parents who enjoy that kind of work.
Either way, you end up with a wonderful keepsake that turns piles of paintings and sketches into something you'll cherish. The best solution is the one that lets you actually get it done. Whether you go pro with Artkive or go hands-on with Shutterfly, you're taking a step that keeps your memories safe. That's always time well spent.
Ready To Let Artkive Take The Reins?
